Skip to content
Watchlist

Consign your graded cards

Submit PSA, BGS, CGC, or SGC graded cards, choose eBay auction, Pulltrader fixed price, or Fanatics Collect auction, then mail them to us or schedule an HQ drop-off appointment. We verify, list, and pay you out when they sell.

How consignment works

  1. Submit your graded cards below in the card list with cert numbers (and asking prices in notes if you choose fixed price).
  2. Mail your cards to us, or schedule an HQ drop-off appointment. Consignment is vaulted — we receive, verify, photograph, and list them. Mail intake:
    Pulltrader
    2150 Pickwick Dr. #939
    Camarillo, CA 93010
    Include your submission barcode (and C/O your consignor ID on the label). You'll get both after you submit below. For Camarillo drop-off, email ryan@pulltrader.app to request an appointment (different address from mail intake).
  3. We sell and pay you out when the item clears. Keep 85% of hammer on eBay auctions, or up to 100% on qualifying premium placements.

Listing formats & payouts

Auction · eBay

External auction

We list a 7-day eBay auction starting at $0.99. No pricing needed from you — maximum reach on eBay.

85%of hammer · all seller levels

Fixed price · Pulltrader + eBay

Pulltrader marketplace

You set the asking price. Buyers can purchase or make offers on Pulltrader. We may also list the same item fixed-price on eBay for extra reach.

91–95%Pulltrader sales · by seller level

85%if it sells fixed-price on eBay

Premium auctions

ALT · Goldin · Fanatics Collect

Eligible items may be placed through premium auction houses. Same mail-in or Camarillo drop-off intake as other consignments. Not every card qualifies — eligibility and format vary by platform.

Up to 100%of hammer on qualifying placements

Seller levels & Pulltrader payouts

Seller level is based only on your sales volume — not your subscription plan. It applies to fixed-price Pulltrader (platform) sales. eBay consignment auctions keep 85% of hammer. Qualifying premium auction placements can keep up to 100% of hammer. There are no submission fees.

LevelYou keepSales volume
Level 191%Entry tier
Level 292%Verified, or a complete profile
Level 393%About $5k/yr in sales
Level 494%About $25k/yr in sales
Level 595%About $50k/yr in sales

Start a submission

A submission is tied to your account so we can pay you out, so you will need to sign in to start one.

Sign in to start a submission