Choose the selling route that fits the card.
Prepare listings from inventory, compare fees, and decide which buyers and fulfillment options suit your stock.
Channel economics differ more than sellers expect.
The same card returns different proceeds by channel. Your own channels cost 3.25% + $0.40 per card transaction, with no separate seller commission; you keep your listed price when the buyer covers the charge. Marketplace has a seller-level fee. Self-managed external sales have no Pulltrader commission; external platform fees still apply.
Without that visible when you set the price, channel choice becomes a habit rather than a decision.
- One number listed everywhere despite different economics
- Inventory sitting on the channel that clears it slowest
- Listing work repeated per channel
- No read on which channel is carrying the business
Selling routes and fulfillment options
Card and account eligibility vary by destination. Connected listing tools, managed fulfillment, and auction placement each have their own requirements.
Your storefront
3.25% + $0.40 per card transaction, with no separate seller commission. You keep your listed price when the buyer covers the charge (default).
In-person POS
Same economics at the counter or a show table, and cash sales carry no checkout fee at all.
Marketplace
Reach buyers browsing Marketplace with eligible listings. A seller-level fee of 5%–9% applies; custody and fulfillment requirements depend on the cards.
Binz
Review fixed payouts and submission requirements for supported low price points before choosing Binz for low-value cards.
External marketplaces, fulfilled by us
Managed external fulfillment is a separate service for approved inventory. Review acceptance, shipping responsibilities, and rates before sending cards.
External, self-managed
Connect eBay for import and listing tools, or cross-list eligible Magic cards to Mana Pool. Self-managed external sales have no Pulltrader commission; the external platform charges its own fees.
Premium auction houses
Auction placement is a consignment service for qualifying cards. Review acceptance, format, and payout terms before submitting.
Dealer-to-dealer
Explore business-to-business selling and consignment when another dealer is a better fit for the inventory.
Choosing where an item sells
Compare the destination with your cards, costs, and fulfillment needs.
What does this channel keep?
Compare the transaction charge, seller-level fee, fixed payout, or managed-service rate. Subtract acquisition cost and the expenses you cover.
Who is the buyer here?
Your own customers, someone at the counter, marketplace browsers, or eBay's audience. They do not behave the same way.
How fast do you need it converted?
Capital sitting in slow inventory has a cost that never appears on an invoice.
Set the price per channel
Review the asking price and supported channel options before preparing or publishing the listing.
Net comparison at a glance
Item value only. Full rates, including fulfillment and consignment, are on the fee schedule.
- Your Storefront, Checkout and POS
- 3.25% + $0.40 per card transaction, with no separate seller commission. You keep your listed price when the buyer covers the charge. Your buyer covers the 3.25% + $0.40 transaction charge by default on Storefront, Checkout and POS card sales; you can choose to cover it in your settings. There is no separate seller commission. Cash POS has no transaction charge.
- Marketplace
- 5%–9% seller-level fee. Review listing eligibility and custody or fulfillment requirements before choosing Marketplace.
- Binz
- Fixed payout per supported price point. Review the schedule and submission requirements for low-value stock.
- External via Fulfilled by Pulltrader
- 85% payout for qualifying managed external sales. Review acceptance and fulfillment terms on the fee schedule.
- External, self-managed
- No Pulltrader commission on self-managed external sales. External platform fees and your fulfillment costs still apply.
- Premium auctions
- Up to 100% of hammer on qualifying auction placements, with no submission fee. Eligibility, format, and payout terms vary.
Questions people ask
How far does the reach actually go?
Your storefront and Checkout, eligible Marketplace listings, and connected eBay tools are available selling routes. Eligible Magic cards can be cross-listed to Mana Pool. Binz, managed external fulfillment, premium auction placement, and dealer services have separate eligibility and terms.
Should I list everything on every channel?
Choose destinations based on card eligibility, buyer audience, fees, and who will fulfill the order. Check availability and connected listing status before offering the same stock in more than one place.
Where do I keep the most?
Compare the fee schedule using your expected price and costs. Storefront and Checkout card transactions cost 3.25% + $0.40, buyer-covered by default, with no separate seller commission. Marketplace charges 5%–9%; external platforms and managed services have their own rates.
Does a sale on one channel remove it from the others?
Review remaining quantity and connected listing status after a sale. External listing updates depend on the connection and destination; check that status before committing more stock.
Reach buyers from the inventory you already manage.
Confirm availability, choose an eligible destination, and compare what remains after costs.